Pdf considered an indicator of selfawareness, mirror selfrecognition msr has long seemed limited to humans and apes. Selfrecognition tests applied on animals through mirrors appear to be a viable alternative to demonstrate the existence of a type of general intelligence. For t3 open mirror, three camera angles were used, one of which, as described previously, was operated from the roof above the elephant yard using a sony tokyo, japan pdf 150 digital video minidv camera. The emergence of self awareness in children typically occurs during the second year and has been correlated with sensorimotor development and growing social and self awareness. Asian elephant conservation act us fish and wildlife service.
Ones own face is the most distinctive feature of the bodily self, and people typically show a clear advantage in recognizing their own face even more than. Such objections claim that turing test is not a tool to demonstrate existence of general intelligence or thinking activity. Moore and diana reiss, journalzoo biology, year2010, volume29 2, pages 17991. Elephants know when their bodies are obstacles to success in a. Thus, this distribution is more or less what one may expect on the basis of the amount of time each subject spent monitoring the mirror. Pdf selfrecognition in the asian elephant and future. Oct 11, 2016 raju the elephant cries tears of joy while being rescued after 50 years of abuse and chains in india duration. Selfrecognition in the asian elephant and future directions for cognitive research with elephants in zoological settings. Raju the elephant cries tears of joy while being rescued after 50 years of abuse and chains in india duration.
The msr test is the traditional method for attempting to measure selfawareness. Selfrecognition in an asian elephant article pdf available in proceedings of the national academy of sciences 10345. Asian elephants are the largest living land animals in asia. Elephants elephas maximus in contrast to their use of mirror cues to discover hidden food. In 2005, the west african elephant memorandum of understanding was signed by 12 west african countries. Pdf selfrecognition in an asian elephant researchgate. The emergence of selfawareness in children typically occurs during the second year and has been correlated with sensorimotor development and growing social and selfawareness. The african elephant specialist group has set up a human elephant conflict task force with the aim to develop conflict mitigation strategies. The african elephant loxodonta is a genus comprising two living elephant species, the african bush elephant l.
They have grey skin and differ in the size of their ears and tusks, and in. This is a pdf file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. The mirror was built and installed over a period of 2 weeks but remained covered during t2 covered mirror. Elephants know when their bodies are obstacles to success. Both topics have been explored in elephants, with somewhat equivocal results. Joshua plotnik and colleagues that demonstrated self awareness in the asian elephant. Compared to the average life expectancy of 70 for a typical asian elephant, lin wang lived much longer and died at the age of 86. Asian elephants recognize their reflections animal cognition.
In the first condition, elephants were simultaneously presented with two identical trays serving as the. Tool use and mirror selfrecognition are often taken to be indications of advanced mental capacity, both in animal cognition and developmental psychology. In this light, alternatives to turing test are to be investigated. The field of animal cognition has grown steadily for nearly four decades, but the primary focus has centered on easily kept lab animals of varying cognitive capacity, including rodents, birds and primates. Living links, yerkes national primate research center, and department of psychology, emory university, atlanta, ga 30322. Global sanctuary for elephants is a 501 c3 tax exempt, public charity status ein 463564818. Elephants loxodonta africana, loxodonta cyclotis, elephas. We used captive asian elephants n 2 to conduct four variations of the piagetian support problem, which involves a goal object that is out of reach, but rests on a support within reach. Mirror selfrecognition msr is exceedingly rare in the animal kingdom 1.
To judge by the wellstudied african elephant loxodonta africana, elephant society may. In a recent test of mirror selfrecognition in three captive asian elephants of the bronx zoo, new york city, a large mirror was placed in the enclosure of the elephants plotnik et al. African elephants are distinguished from asian elephants in several ways, the most noticeable being their ears which are much larger. A previous failed attempt to demonstrate msr in two asian elephants presented the animals with a relatively small mirror that was kept at a distance, well out of trunkreach. Paleocene emergence of elephant relatives and the rapid radiation of african ungulates. Rather, it may be more useful first to understand the building blocks of an elephants cognitive system. Given previous instances of success on the selfrecognition test in asian elephants 10, and high levels of success during pilot work of the bodyawareness task with captive african elephants.
In the wild, elephants can live to be about 70 years old. Elephants know when their bodies are obstacles to success in. The present study explores to what extent asian elephants show meansend behavior. Self recognition in the asian elephant and future directions for cognitive research with elephants in zoological settings. Happy the elephant faq on october 2, 2018, the nonhuman rights project nhrp initiated habeas corpus litigation on behalf of the elephant happy, demanding recognition of her fundamental right to liberty and her release to an elephant sanctuary. Despite the increasing interest in twin studies and the stunning amount of research on face recognition, the ability of adult identical twins to discriminate their own faces from those of their cotwins has been scarcely investigated. Of the two published accounts of mirror self recognition tests in asian elephants, one was negative and.
We exposed three asian elephants elephas maximus to a large mirror to investigate their responses. The asian elephant is primarily threatened by loss of habitat, habitat degradation, fragmentation and poaching. Apr 12, 2017 elephants body awareness adds to increasing evidence of their intelligence asian elephants are able to recognise their bodies as obstacles to success in problemsolving, further strengthening evidence of their intelligence and selfawareness, according to a new study from the university of cambridge. Elephants have high social intelligence 25, the ability to solve cooperative tasks 26 and they show signs of selfrecognition. Apr 12, 2017 given previous instances of success on the self recognition test in asian elephants 10, and high levels of success during pilot work of the bodyawareness task with captive african elephants. Plotnik, the founder of think elephants international, is a researcher of animal intelligence, with published work on mirror selfrecognition in asian elephants. The existential elephant the mirror selfrecognition msr test identifies critical levels of cognitive development, the ability to engage in abstract psychological levels of knowing that relate to the theory of mind tom, indicating that one is not only conscious but selfconscious. Tool using and self recognition abilities, though important for humans, may not be the best place to begin a rigorous investigation of elephant cognition. Of the two published accounts of mirror selfrecognition tests in asian elephants, one was negative and. Abstract the field of animal cognition has grown steadily for nearly four decades, but the primary focus has centered on easily kept lab animals.
Elephants can recognize themselves in a mirror, joining only humans, apes and dolphins as animals that possess this kind of selfawareness, researchers now report. Failure to find selfrecognition in asian elephants elephas. Great apes and humans, unlike small apes and monkeys, have repeatedly passed mirror tests, suggesting that the underlying brain processes are. Rather, it may be more useful first to understand the building blocks of an elephant s cognitive system.
Elephants have the advantage that they can touch most of their own body with their trunks, thus permitting an unequivocal mark test. The mirror testsometimes called the mark test, mirror selfrecognition test msr, red spot technique, or rouge testis a behavioural technique developed in 1970 by psychologist gordon gallup jr. The nature of visual selfrecognition sciencedirect. Nov 07, 2006 the mirror was built and installed over a period of 2 weeks but remained covered during t2 covered mirror. Evaluating the personality structure of semicaptive asian elephants. Tool using and selfrecognition abilities, though important for humans, may not be the best place to begin a rigorous investigation of elephant cognition. Selfrecognition in the asian elephant and future directions for cognitive research with elephants in zoological settings article in zoo biology 292.
Evidence of meansend behavior in asian elephants elephas. Mirror self recognition msr is a behavioral indicator of self awareness in young children and only a few other species, including the great apes, dolphins, elephants and magpies. Tool use and mirror self recognition are often taken to be indications of advanced mental capacity, both in animal cognition and developmental psychology. Considered an indicator of selfawareness, mirror selfrecognition msr has long seemed limited to humans and apes. Part of the problem with studying consciousness is measuring it.
View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. Basic elephant facts global sanctuary for elephants. Elephants exhibit mirror self recognition, an indication of self awareness and cognition that has also been demonstrated in some apes and dolphins. Given previous instances of success on the selfrecognition test in asian elephants, and high levels of success during pilot work of the. In a survey of 4,500 captive elephants worldwide, among african elephants, zooborn females live an average of 16. Mirrorself recognition msr is a behavioral indicator of selfawareness in young children and only a few other species, including the great apes, dolphins, elephants and magpies.
Great apes and humans, unlike small apes and monkeys, have repeatedly passed mirror tests, suggesting that the underlying brain processes are homologous and evolved 1418 million years ago. Mirror self recognition msr is exceedingly rare in the animal kingdom 1. Joshua plotnik and colleagues that demonstrated selfawareness in the asian elephant. In a carefully designed test of seven chimpanzees, three met the stage4 criterion of selfrecognition povinelli et al. The asian or asiatic elephant elephas maximus is the only living species of the genus elephas and is distributed in southeast asia from india and nepal in the west to borneo in the east. One study of a captive female asian elephant suggested the animal was capable of learning and distinguishing between several visual and some acoustic discrimination pairs. The department of psychology at hunter college of the city university of new york cuny invites applications for a tenuretrack position at the assistant, associate, or full professor level in animal behavior, with a focus on applied andor basic research in canine behavior and cognition the.
Elephants body awareness adds to increasing evidence of. Nov 07, 2006 considered an indicator of self awareness, mirror self recognition msr has long seemed limited to humans and apes. Apart from humans and apes, dolphins and elephants are also known for such capacities. In a study out this week in the proceedings of the national academy of sciences u. Compared to the average life expectancy of 70 for a typical asian elephant, lin wang lived much longer and died at. Osborn laboratories of marine ces, new york aquarium, wildlife conservation society, brooklyn, ny 11224. It includes the basics of species and size to self recognition. The african elephant is typically larger than the asian elephant and has a concave back. Pdf selfrecognition in an asian elephant diana reiss. Precocious development of selfawareness in dolphins. Thinking like an elephant in thailand 20 7 research aims the golden triangle asian elephant foundation gtaef, the thai nonprofit organization that will host you on this expedition, was founded to give streetbegging elephants from bangkok and their mahouts, or caretakers, a good home. Selfrecognition in an asian elephant, pnas,103,1705317057.
Lin wang 811 words exact match in snippet view article find links to article wang. Elephant selfawareness mirrors humans live science. Elephants exhibit mirror selfrecognition, an indication of selfawareness and cognition that has also been demonstrated in some apes and dolphins. The fallacy of signature whistles in bottlenose dolphins. After the recent discovery of msr in dolphins tursiops truncatus. Dec 18, 2007 the present study explores to what extent asian elephants show meansend behavior. Selfrecognition in the asian elephant and future directions. Elephants body awareness adds to increasing evidence of their intelligence asian elephants are able to recognise their bodies as obstacles to success in problemsolving, further strengthening evidence of their intelligence and selfawareness, according to a new study from the university of cambridge. Jan 11, 2015 mirror self recognition in asian elephants. Considered an indicator of self awareness, mirror self recognition msr has long seemed limited to humans and apes. In one of his past studies 2, he administered the mirror test to three asian elephants. In both phylogeny and human ontogeny, msr is thought to correlate with higher forms of empathy and altruistic behavior. Since 1986, the asian elephant has been listed as endangered on the iucn red list as the population has declined by at least 50 percent over the last three generations, estimated to be 6075 years.
1538 980 419 995 168 719 899 1380 980 1329 343 429 9 1063 1100 207 1450 19 369 1327 1231 38 1294 800 589 293 493 590 981 1363 108 530 1238 1047 1117 1422 1452 1023 1395 77 590 638 649 741 32 1393 1223 250 365 590 925